Great British Menu judges sacked
Introduction: A Show Full of Change and Misunderstandings
Great British Menu judges sacked, the long-running BBC competition, has captivated viewers with its blend of high-end culinary creations, intense competition, and the dynamic presence of its panel of judges. Yet, despite its enduring popularity, the show has been surrounded by controversy and mystery when it comes to the departures of its esteemed judges.
One of the most talked-about rumors is that various judges have been “Great British Menu judges sacked”, leaving fans confused and intrigued. This speculation has been amplified across social media platforms and tabloid headlines. But what’s the truth? Were the judges truly fired, or is there more to the story?
In this article, we will set the record straight by reviewing the key judge departures over the years, examining why they happened, and clarifying the common misconception that these judges were sacked.
What is Great British Menu judges sacked?
For those who may be unfamiliar, Great British Menu is a celebrated British culinary competition that first aired in 2006. The format pits professional chefs against one another in a series of regional heats to create exceptional dishes for a prestigious banquet. Each episode features a new round where chefs compete in various categories, and the judging panel decides which dishes will make the cut.
Over the years, the judging panel has seen several shifts. The panel is often composed of celebrated chefs, food critics, and restaurateurs, and their role is to evaluate the chefs’ creativity, skill, and ability to produce dishes worthy of a high-profile banquet. Given the show’s high profile, the judges’ positions have attracted significant attention, and their departures have led to intense speculation.
Judge Departures: Was Anyone Ever Great British Menu judges sacked “Sacked”?
The most persistent rumor surrounding Great British Menu has been that its judges have been “@Great British Menu judges sacked“ under dramatic circumstances. In reality, however, many of these departures were simply natural transitions rather than any dramatic firings. Let’s explore the key moments in the evolution of the judging panel and clarify these misunderstandings.
1. Matthew Fort & Oliver Peyton (2022)
Matthew Fort, the food critic, and Oliver Peyton, the restaurateur, were two of the longest-serving and most recognizable faces on the Great British Menu panel. They appeared regularly since the show’s early years and were instrumental in shaping its distinct flavor and atmosphere.
However, in 2022, both Fort and Peyton announced their departure from the show. This led to a flurry of media speculation, with some outlets hinting that they were being “Great British Menu judges sacked”. In reality, their exit was not due to any scandal or firing — it was a well-planned transition.
The BBC officially confirmed their departure as part of an effort to refresh the judging panel. The network wanted to bring in new personalities with different backgrounds to keep the format fresh and dynamic. This was not an uncommon decision in long-running TV series. Both Fort and Peyton had long and successful careers, and after more than a decade of service on the show, they were ready to move on to new projects. There were no indications of animosity, nor was there any public statement suggesting they were “sacked”.
2. Rachel Khoo (2021)
In 2021, renowned chef and author Rachel Khoo joined the panel as a guest judge for the season. However, she only appeared in that season and did not return for future editions.
There was speculation that her short tenure was due to behind-the-scenes disagreements or an issue with the producers, but in reality, Khoo’s departure was due to scheduling conflicts and personal choices. She had other commitments and did not return to the panel — not because she was fired or “Great British Menu judges sacked”. It was a short stint for Khoo, and fans of the show simply missed her presence, which led to the rumour mill grinding on.
3. Ed Gamble (2025)
Comedian and podcast host Ed Gamble joined the judging panel in 2022 to bring a fresh, humorous touch to the show. His witty remarks and light-hearted demeanor made him a popular figure with fans. However, after three seasons, Ed Gamble decided to step down in 2025, sparking rumors of a dramatic exit.
Once again, these rumors were completely unfounded. Ed’s departure was a voluntary decision — as he wanted to focus on other projects, such as his stand-up career, podcasts, and television appearances. The BBC confirmed his departure was amicable and that he was replaced by Phil Wang, another comedian with a passion for food. Gamble himself expressed gratitude for his time on the show and gave a glowing farewell to the Great British Menu family.
4. Nisha Katona & Lorna McNee (2024–2025)
In 2024, chef and restaurateur Nisha Katona left her position on the panel after serving as a judge for several seasons. Her exit was framed as a natural career progression, as she sought to focus on her growing restaurant business and media endeavors. Katona’s departure was not marked by any tension or firing rumors. Instead, the show welcomed Lorna McNee, a rising star in the culinary world, to take over her seat.
This transition was seamless and is a testament to how the show evolves over time. Just like many other successful shows, Great British Menu regularly refreshes its panel to introduce new perspectives, ensuring that it remains relevant and engaging for its audience. No one was “Great British Menu judges sacked”; it was simply a case of business as usual for a dynamic television format.
Why Do People Think Judges Were Great British Menu judges sacked?
Given that no judges were officially “sacked”, why do these rumors persist? There are a few key reasons:
1. Media Sensationalism
Many smaller media outlets, desperate for clicks, often use dramatic headlines such as “Great British Menu judges sacked” to attract attention. These sensationalist headlines don’t reflect the reality of the situation, which is usually far more mundane. While it’s true that some judges have left or been replaced over the years, they have done so for a variety of reasons — personal growth, scheduling conflicts, or the desire to pursue other professional opportunities — not because they were fired or “Great British Menu judges sacked”.
2. Fan Reactions to Casting Changes
Fans of the show can be very passionate about the judges, especially those who have been around for a long time. When a beloved judge leaves, whether by choice or for any other reason, fans often express their disappointment. This can give rise to rumors about the judge being dismissed or sacked, even when the reality is simply a normal change in the show’s lineup.
For example, when Matthew Fort and Oliver Peyton left, many fans were upset, and social media exploded with speculation about the reasons for their departure. But once again, these departures were planned and amicable. The use of the word “sacked” here was more a reflection of fans’ frustration than anything factual.
3. The Nature of TV Shows and Contracts
Judges on long-running TV shows are often on fixed-term contracts. After a few years, the producers may opt to refresh the panel to keep the content fresh. When judges leave, it’s often seen as part of the natural turnover of a series rather than something negative like a firing. These transitions are common across the entertainment industry and are not usually motivated by any personal conflicts or issues with the judges themselves.
Conclusion: The Bottom Line
The idea that Great British Menu judges have been “Great British Menu judges sacked” is a misleading myth. While it’s true that judges have come and gone over the years, these departures have been part of the natural evolution of the show, not due to scandals or firings.
From Matthew Fort and Oliver Peyton’s departures to Ed Gamble’s amicable exit and the ongoing rotation of judges, Great British Menu continues to adapt and thrive. Its producers have consistently made the right decisions to refresh the panel, allowing new talent to shine while honoring the legacy of those who helped build the show into the beloved format it is today.
As fans, it’s important to separate fact from fiction. Judges leave shows all the time for a variety of reasons, and the departure of a favorite personality doesn’t always mean there’s been drama behind the scenes. In the case of Great British Menu, it’s simply part of the show’s continual reinvention.
About the Author
